Interview: Stanford University Emeritus Professor, legal scholar Michael Wald speaks to Gay Marriage and Christian issues–by Peter Menkin

Free Online Articles Directory

Why Submit Articles?
Top Authors
Top Articles
FAQ
ABAnswers

Publish Article

0 && $. browser. msie ) {
var ie_version = parseInt($. browser. version);
if(ie_version Login

Login via

Register
Hello
My Home
Sign Out

Email
Password

Remember me?Lost Password?

Home Page > Home and Family > Parenting > Interview: Stanford University Emeritus Professor, legal scholar Michael Wald speaks to Gay Marriage and Christian issues–by Peter Menkin

Interview: Stanford University Emeritus Professor, legal scholar Michael Wald speaks to Gay Marriage and Christian issues–by Peter Menkin

Edit Article |

Posted: Aug 14, 2010 |Comments: 0
|

]]>

Stanford University, Palo Alto, California (located in Northern California, USA) offered the availability of an esteemed law professor for commentary on Judge Vaughn Walker’s legal opinion regarding gay marriage in the State being declined; it originally passed through a voter initiative known as Proposition 8. Emeritus Professor Michael Wald generously agreed to a fuller interview on Gay Marriage, and some of its effects of its dimension on Christian issues of “discrimination” based on Christian beliefs.  
Professor Wald has been involved in these issues of Gay Marriage for a number of years and related areas of concern, engaging in work in favor of Gay Marriage, being involved in public debates (Pace Law School), and as a legal scholar in children’s rights, is published in notable fashion extensively. The reader may want to note that Professor Wald in his interview with this writer done by email and via telephone call (lasting an hour) offers a legal scholar’s secular scope of discourse and educated commentary on the questions.
 
 
THE INTERVIEW
 
Please let us know Professor, as a start, what it means to be an Emeritus Professor at Stanford University, Palo Alto, California and tell us about the Jackson Eli Reynolds Professor of Law Chair. Also, as part of this introduction, I see you were a Guggenheim Fellow, 1982-1983. What was your area of study? You’ve also been at Stanford University since 1967. Have you liked the school all those years, and if you were to tell us what in those years was most significant to you, what would it be.
 
An Emeritus Professor is retired. I still retain a position at the university. I no longer teach classes on a regular basis, but still work with students and conduct research.  I teach on children and family policy. I hold the Jackson Reynolds Chair. Being given a chair is a way for faculty to be given some kind of honor. I have, throughout my career, also done a lot of government service related to children’s welfare.
 
Let us turn to the legal questions regarding Gay Marriage & Christians, now that we’ve learned a little about you as a Professor. By the way, I see you were deputy general counsel for the U. S. Department of Health and Human Services during the Clinton administration, executive director of the San Francisco Department of Human Services. First about children:
 
 
1.       Is adoption by gay couples really a social experiment on children? Though this has political ramifications, what of their welfare and health? Is it fair for the law to regulate culture and religious observance when it comes to religion’s formal declarations of activity; a specific issue is the Catholic Church and Gay adoption.
 
No. Adoption by gay couples or individuals is not an experiment on children. It clearly benefits children to be adopted if their parents cannot care for them.  The evidence is clear that children adopted by gay parents do just as well as those adopted by heterosexual parents.    
 
Moreover, it must be understood that the issue for most of these children is whether they will be adopted at all or be left to impermanent upbringing. Most often, children adopted by same sex parents do not have other families looking to adopt them and they would be raised in institutions or foster care if they are not adopted. . . It is definitely better for these children to be adopted, since adoption provides stability and much greater parental commitment…in all adoption situations, 
 
The adoption agency and courts are required to protect the child’s best interests and place the child in a family that best fits the needs of the individual child. The law in the United States does not require Catholic adoption agencies, or other adoption agencies with religious affiliations…that they have to consider place gay couples or any other couples for adoption, unless the agency receives funds from the state to do adoption services.
 
When an organization, religious or other kind, receives funds from the state to perform a state function, such as adoption, that organization has to do so on a basis that is non-discriminatory and that meets the goals of the law. Thus, an adoption agency that receives state funds cannot refuse to place children with couples that are Jewish or Black or interracial; all couples who apply for adoption with state agencies will be considered and it must be determined on a case by case basis what is best for the child.  If a Catholic or any other agency wanted to work only with couples of a certain religion or sexual orientation, it could do so but not with State funds. ,
 
 
 
2.       A recent case that went before the Supreme Court considered issues of Christian conscience and freedom of religion regarding membership of gay students at a California law school in a Christian club. The Court said that was discrimination. Some fear this ruling as a precursor to an attitude of forcing Christians to bend their religious faith to conform to legal rights set by society regarding its concern for gay people. How do you think this will be acted on as a trend and attitude maker regarding future laws and Christian religious rights? Does it inhibit Christians in their faith? Is this fair, and is it an uncommon legal result in other public issues?
 
Basically, this case raises the same issues as the adoption case. The Christian Law Group at Hastings Law School could limit membership to whomever they want. But once they want to use law school space, all organizations must follow general law school policy.
 
The law school, which is publicly funded, had a rule that all clubs or organizations that were recognized or received support from the School had to be open to all law students. No organization could limit membership based on an applicant’s race, ethnicity, sexual orientation, religion or other such factor. The rule is if you want to be an organization with formal recognition of the law school, you need to be open to all students. The Court decision would have been the same if the applicant had been an atheist and therefore rejected.
 
 
 
3.       What difference is there between the secular and the religious marriage, as you see it in this public area? And secondly, in some denominations the minister or Priest performs a wedding and acts for the state in signing a marriage license. Some ministers, in specific Priests in the San Francisco Bay Area who are Episcopalian, refuse to act for the State because it makes them agents of discrimination at this time when Gay Marriage is illegal. They think it should be legalized, so have refused to do so. Significantly, some even refuse to perform marriages at all as a Sacrament as protest because within the Church, Gay Marriage is not equal to traditional marriage. The question is specifically, what kind of turmoil do you see in legal and public acceptance of Gay Marriage and especially Christians judging by the turmoil the controversy already has caused. Is it worth it, in the ethically legal sense?
 
In the public arena, there is only secular marriage. Marriage is a set of legal commitments between two individuals. The requirements for marriage are established by state law.
 
Religious communities in giving marriages a religious blessing may set other regulations. For a long time the Catholic Church and the Church of England did not let people who were divorced get married in a religious ceremony; but those people could still marry under secular law. . . Ministers of different faiths are authorized to perform marriages, as are judges and some other officials. However, no minister is required to perform a marriage he or she does not want to perform. No judge is required to perform a marriage he or she does not want to perform. The only people who must perform a marriage when requested are county clerks. Religious officials are just one group of officials who may perform marriages, but they do not have to perform them.
 
There is obviously a great deal of controversy regarding same sex couple marriage. From my perspective as a scholar of family law…marriage, in general, is a good thing for the adults and for the children. It is an equally good thing for same sex couples and their children as it is for opposite sex couples and their children. While recognizing same sex marriages creates some turmoil, it is certainly worth the controversy, because in my judgment it is good for society.
 
The evidence in places like Massachusetts, Sweden, Denmark, and the other countries and states that have recognized same sex marriage for some time is that there is no ongoing turmoil. The public comes to accept and value these marriages. Interestingly, some very religious countries, Spain, Mexico, Argentina, have recently adopted a policy of recognizing marriage of same sex couples.
 
 
4.       Will people in social work fields and counseling have their jobs protected if they conscientiously or religiously refuse to work with gay couples? This is a particularly significant area as some have lost their jobs and even careers over such issues. You may be familiar with some of these cases.
 
The issue of when a social worker, doctor, pharmacist or other professional cannot refuse to provide services to a particular group of people is complicated and not fully resolved.  Various constitutional rights sometimes are in conflict, including rules on non-discrimination, rules relating to freedom of association, and rules relating to property rights. The courts have tried to strike a balance. I cannot fully address the complexities here. However, when one must provide services…it is possible that social workers and counselors may be required to provide some services, depending on the circumstances.
 
For example, in California, landlords must make their rental property available in a non-discriminatory manner. Landlords may not say they will not rent to gay couples or Black couples or those of a particular religion. . .  When you open your business to the public, the law says you have to do it on a non-discriminatory basis. Because we are a country that values individual freedom and properties rights and freedom of association, there is a tension between the public goal of preventing discrimination and these other public goals: freedom of association, property rights, etc. The law in the United States has generally resolved these by saying that the value of non-discrimination is more important than these other values.
 
We’ve previously talked about how the goal of non-discrimination has been seen as limiting some other rights of people, as in the case of a landlord not being allowed to discriminate in renting her or his property. Now whether people in counseling fields who hold themselves out to the public should have to counsel people is a difficult balance. [To probe more deeply. ] We don’t want discrimination.
 
There is a relationship between counselors and people being counseled that requires some degree of relationship. So the balance may be different. And it hasn’t as much public rejection, as a restaurant or a rental unit. On the other hand, for certain types of jobs where people have a very important kind of function, for example pharmacists…pharmacists cannot refuse to give people birth control pills…. pharmacists have to give what medications are prescribed by doctors. They cannot give patients medicines based on their religious beliefs. Similarly, if a social worker worked for a public agency or took public dollars for their practice, like Catholic charities… if organizations want to use public money to support the services they are offering, then in almost all situations, we have decided and I agree with this decision… these services have to be decided on a non-discriminatory basis.
 
 
5.       In England, Gay Rights trump Christian religious sensibilities and public practice by individuals to a confining extent. At least judging by a number of cases, especially a notorious one where a nurse prayed a Christian prayer for a patient in a hospital and spoke to her about faith and healing in the patient’s hospital bed. She was severely reprimanded and suspended, if memory serves correct. The point is does the legal broadening of Gay Rights shake the social fabric in a way that constrains and influences public attitudes and social practices in discriminatory ways towards Christians?
 
I don’t know the facts of this case; it is a general duty of doctors and nurses to perform their duties in a manner that is very sensitive to the patient’s sensibilities and well being. If a patient doesn’t want counseling of a religious or of any other nature, it would be bad professional conduct for a doctor or nurse to do that.
 
For some patients, it may give them a great deal of comfort if a nurse prayed for them, for others, this would be unacceptable. The helping professional must be very careful that her or his actions are what the patient wants. It’s my understanding that Chaplains and other professionals are trained to approach the person in the way that is most helpful to each individual. If it’s with religious support they will do it; if not with religious support they will find a way that helps them.
 
 
6.       That’s the question list I’ve prepared for our interview, and at this time I ask if you’d like to add anything of your choosing, or make some statement on the subject.
 
Obviously the issue of same sex marriage raises a number of fundamental value issues for people. Some people have criticized Judge Walker in the Proposition 8 case for overruling the vote of a public majority. They say it is wrong for a judge to be able to overrule the will of the people. However, that’s what the Constitution was designed to do–to have courts protect minorities from majority rule in certain situations.  
 
For example, the judges over-ruled the will of the people in many states to keep Black students in segregated schools. Just recently, the Justices of the U. S. Supreme Court over ruled the will of the people of Chicago and the District of Columbia, to limit the possession of guns.   
 
These gun bans reflected “the will of the people” but the Justices said they violated the constitutional rights of the minority of people who want to possess guns.  Judge Walker’s striking down Proposition 8 as unconstitutional is the same as the Supreme Court declaring Chicago’s ban of handguns illegal.
End interview
 
 

Retrieved from “http://www. articlesbase. com/parenting-articles/interview-stanford-university-emeritus-professor-legal-scholar-michael-wald-speaks-to-gay-marriage-and-christian-issues-by-peter-menkin-3042729. html”

(ArticlesBase SC #3042729)

Watch your traffic increase just by submitting articles with us, click here to get started.
Liked this article? Click here to publish it on your website or blog, it’s free and easy!

Peter Menkin -
About the Author:Peter Menkin, an aspiring poet, lives in Mill Valley, CA USA (north of San Francisco). My blog: http://www. petermenkin. blogspot. com He is 63 years old as of 2009.

]]>

Questions and Answers

Ask our experts your Parenting related questions here. . .

Ask

200 Characters left

How is gay marriage a civil rights issue ?
How many states have legalized gay marriage ?
How many us states legalized gay marriage ?

Rate this Article

1
2
3
4
5

vote(s)
0 vote(s)

Feedback
RSS
Print
Email
Re-Publish

Source:  http://www. articlesbase. com/parenting-articles/interview-stanford-university-emeritus-professor-legal-scholar-michael-wald-speaks-to-gay-marriage-and-christian-issues-by-peter-menkin-3042729. html

Article Tags:
gay marriage, stanford university, michael wald, interview

Related Videos

Latest Parenting Articles
More from Peter Menkin

Cynthia Nixon Says Gays Don’t Want to Redefine Marriage

“Sex and the City” star Cynthia Nixon weighs in on the gay marriage debate. “Gay people who want to marry have no desire to redefine marriage in any way,” she says. “When women got the vote, they did not redefine voting. “Justice in its (01:50)

The Emotional Meaning of Gay Marriage

Proposition 8 would change the California State Constitution to eliminate the right of same-sex couples to marry. In this emotion-laden issue, supporters and opponents of same-sex marriage are grappling with whether amending the constitution to strip rights from some Californians is wise policy. What is the impact on families and society as a whole? Paul Thorndal offers his insight. (04:17)

DC Christian Charities Threaten to Deny Service to Gays

As christian charities threaten to deny service if gay marriage laws pass, StuartProductions brings you this interview with a DC homeless woman. (05:59)

Would the Founding Fathers Have Supported Gay Marriage

Former United States Solicitor Generals Walter Dellinger and Paul Clement agree that framing-era documents provide no hints as to Constitutional issues around same-sex marriage. Dellinger adds that the 14th Amendment fundamentally changed the authority of the federal government in the protection of individual rights. (05:48)

Why Judge Walker’s Prop 8 Ruling Was Hasty

NYU Law School professor Richard Epstein and UC Berkeley Law School professor John Yoo apply their legal minds to some recent and upcoming legal challenges in the U. S. Supreme Court. Hear their take on the constitutionality of on gay marriage and prop 8. (04:29)

Learn to Encourage Your Kids to Volunteer

If you want to teach your kids how to be more responsible and yet have some fun, then you should get them involved in several volunteer organizations. And as parents, you can help encourage that.

By:
Nelson Berryl

Home and Family>
Parentingl
Apr 11, 2011

Learn to Control Excessive Tantrums of Your Kids

One of the things parents don’t really like to deal when it comes to their children is a tantrum. It stresses out not only the parents but also the kids.

By:
Nelson Berryl

Home and Family>
Parentingl
Apr 11, 2011

How to Stop Wetting the Bed – Effective Tips for For Both Adults And Children

Some people suffer from a condition called enuresis, which is simply known as bed-wetting. This is the act of wetting the bed during sleep. This is a normal act for children, especially young ones, but is often just a part of a person’s development. At a certain age in childhood, people usually pass this stage. However, some people seem to get stuck with bed-wetting, which develops into a medical condition in their case. According to studies, this condition more commonly affect boys.

By:
Nelson Berryl

Home and Family>
Parentingl
Apr 11, 2011

Handling Naughty Children – How to Stay Calm in a Rowdy Household

Are the little kids being a little too naughty lately? Have they entered that extremely challenging phase in every parent’s life? This phase can be highly stressful. With all the stress at work, the last thing you need is a rowdy household to come home to.

By:
Nelson Berryl

Home and Family>
Parentingl
Apr 11, 2011

Making Use of Children’s Bed Guards

Baby bed guards is very useful for child safety. Here are few important things on selecting bed guards.

By:
Jackie Porterl

Home and Family>
Parentingl
Apr 11, 2011

Troubled Teenagers – Identifying and Dealing With Tough Issues

Teenagers need help and guidance, but it can sometimes be difficult for parents to recognize when to intervene in their teen’s life. Today’s teenagers face different problems and challenges than those you experienced as a teen. Emotional pain and distress can be expressed in many different ways. Some are healthy, some are not. Being able to tell the difference between normal teenage behavior and self-destructive, hurtful behavior is crucial.

By:
Christina Bottol

Home and Family>
Parentingl
Apr 10, 2011

Connecting with God at an Ohio Christian Camp

As parents research the wide variety of camping options in Ohio, looking into all that an Ohio Christian camp has to offer is a great place to start. This article discusses some of the benefits of these camping experiences.

By:
Mark Dublerl

Home and Family>
Parentingl
Apr 10, 2011

The Top 5 Most Popular Products by Beka

Beka has a lot of products. Read on to know what their top 5 products are.

By:
Jayzar Recintol

Home and Family>
Parentingl
Apr 10, 2011

Interview: Marie Howe talks of her poetry

This interview with Marie Howe, American poet and teacher, is the first of a series of three different interviews with American poets. Note some poems by Marie from her new book “The Kingdom of Ordinary Time,” are included in the Addendum to the interview—by permission of the poet, and of W. W. Norton publisher. The new book can be bought through the internet at this address. To contact the poet with an interest in a speaking engagement, go here.

By:
Peter Menkinl

Arts & Entertainment>
Literature l
Apr 02, 2011

Film Review: Excellent film and a please go-see ‘Of Gods and Men’ by Peter Menkin

This well wrought film with its many awards (first prize) from Cannes, New York, and other important places gives a fine dramatic look at a monastery in Algeria caught in the Algerian revolution, a throw-the-French-out historic event set in the later 1990’s. A true film based on the historic story, and a dramatic rendering of excellence, the language of prayers with the use of introspective reflection on their situation by the monks of the monastery hold a poetic lilt.

By:
Peter Menkinl

Arts & Entertainment>
Moviesl
Mar 12, 2011

Arizona Shooting USA, a commentary by Sharon Watkins of Disciples of Christ (by Peter Menkin)

The General Minister of Disciples of Christ told her membership she was in the Chapel in the morning of January 10, 2011 at their Disciples Center in Indianapolis, Indiana, regarding the Arizona shooting. Sharon Watkins observed a moment of silence as called for by President Obama “to honor the innocent victims of the senseless tragedy in Tucson, Arizona, including those still fighting for their lives. It will be a time for us to come together as a nation in p

By:
Peter Menkinl

News and Society>
Politicsl
Feb 07, 2011

Day in the Life of a Bishop’s Wife’, Jeanne Provenzano interviewed in Long Island, New York

In this warm and thoughtful interview, a Bishop’s Wife tells us something of her “Day. ” I note that the first wife in this series offers in her official biography a few salient points worth quoting here as introduction: Jeanne M. Provenzano was born in Waterford, Connecticut, to Arthur and Edna Ross, the fourth of five children and the only girl in the family. Her father worked for the United States Postal Service and her mother was a nurse who worked in several different medical fields.

By:
Peter Menkinl

Relationships>
Marriagel
Feb 03, 2011

Obituary: Nelee Langmuir’s escape from Nazis as Hidden Child

Introduction. Before Nelee Langmuir’s death in Summer, 2010, her daughter wrote of her mother’s experience as a Hidden Child. She wrote of it 2005, September 3 and Debra Wanner in so doing added her voice as a new generation to her mother’s story. Here she serves as an introduction to the condensed narrative that follows of Nelee’s oral history that tells of her remembrance of that time in her childhood, and that of her sister’s, when through the help of good people in France,. . .

By:
Peter Menkinl

News and Society>
Journalisml
Dec 20, 2010

Visit to Oakland’s new Cathedral of Christ the Light by Peter Menkin

The Great Continental Divide in the Western States in America defines water running east or west. Not just a geologic formation in its younger age 100 million years ago, this awesome and continent defining set of snow-capped mountains offers the barrier of imagination through which migrating Americans traveled to come to what are now States like California (38 million residents).

By:
Peter Menkinl

News and Society>
Culturel
Dec 20, 2010

Review: Yale magazine ‘Reflections” article on Millennium Development Goals by Peter Menkin

With permission to quote at length as a spin off report on Yale Divinity School’s Fall, 2010 Issue of “Reflections” magazine, this writer is taking liberties with their thematic statement (“No More Excuses: Confronting Poverty”). The twice yearly published slick magazine approached the September, 2010 United Nations discussion on Millennium Development Goals (MDG), and a seminar at Yale on that subject, by a panel of noteworthy people, speaks to the issues. . .

By:
Peter Menkinl

News and Society>
Economicsl
Dec 20, 2010

Interview: Night Ministry in San Francisco with Reverend Lyle Beckman by Peter Menkin

In a visit to an excellent show on Night Ministry in San Francisco this writer was introduced to the photo work of a young man named Malcolm Garland. Though Malcolm, once a student at The Cathedral School for Boys–(Grace Cathedral, San Francisco)–and now a college student, is a good photographer, it was more than the pictures themselves that were intriguing and genuine. It was Night Ministry in San Francisco itself that became a central focus of interest for this article-interview. . .

By:
Peter Menkinl

News and Society>
Causes & Organizationsl
Dec 20, 2010

Add new Comment

Your Name: *

Your Email:

Comment Body: *

Verification code:*

* Required fields

Submit Your Articles Here It’s Free and easy
Sign Up Today

Author Navigation

My Home
Publish Article
View/Edit Articles
View/Edit Q&A
Edit your Account
Manage Authors
Statistics Page
Personal RSS Builder
My Home
Edit your Account
Update Profile
View/Edit Q&A
Publish Article
Author Box

Peter Menkin has 177 articles online

Contact Author

Subscribe to RSS

Print article

Send to friend

Re-Publish article

Articles Categories
All Categories

Advertising
Arts & Entertainment
Automotive
Beauty
Business
Careers
Computers
Education
Finance
Food and Beverage
Health
Hobbies
Home and Family
Home Improvement
Internet
Law
Marketing
News and Society
Relationships
Self Improvement
Shopping
Spirituality
Sports and Fitness
Technology
Travel
Writing

Home and Family

Accessories
Babies
Elderly Care
Fathering
Genealogy
Holidays
Parenting
Pets
Pregnancy
Teenagers

]]>

Need Hеlр?
Contact Uѕ
FAQ
Submit Articles
Editorial Guidelines
Blog

Site Links
Recent Articles
Top Authors
Top Articles
Find Articles
Site Map
Mobile Version

Webmasters
RSS Builder
RSS
Link tο Uѕ

Business Info
Advertising

Uѕе οf thіѕ web site constitutes acceptance οf thе Terms Of Uѕе аnd Privacy Policy | User published content іѕ licensed under a Creative Commons License. Copyright © 2005-2011 Free Articles bу ArticlesBase. com, All rights reserved.